Do Reviewers Really Matter?

Let’s get into our collective way-back machines to 2005, when newspaper and magazine reviewers were pretty much the only game in town when it came to restaurant ratings. They were feared, revered and rarely questioned or disputed. One of my favorite critics here in town was Joe Pollock who has written many books on our dining and entertainment scene here in Saint Louis and now has a web site dedicated to dining and entertainment. Many restaurants tried lots of things to impress Joe; he was a very noticeable figure, to get highest rating from the paper.

But now, we have Yelpers, Tweeters and about a million bloggers weighing in on your restaurant, posting photos and opinions. While I think it’s a good idea to let everyone weigh in, more often than not I’m frustrated to see scathing reviews of restaurants for all the wrong reasons, such as the Yelper who dinged us because we wanted her to either purchase a cake from us or we would charge a cutting fee for serving another establishment’s cake in our restaurant.  Or the guy who panned a restaurant for charging an automatic gratuity on separate checks when the group had multiple discounts coupons all this makes me wish there was only professional reviewers, with their experience, perspective and professionalism.

But how about you? At this point, what matters more to you and your business? Newspaper and magazine reviews or the guy sitting at your bar taking photos for his blog with an iPhone? I’d love to hear your thoughts.

This entry was posted in Fine Dining in St. Louis, Kirkwood-Restaurants, St. Louis Restaurants and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Do Reviewers Really Matter?

  1. amanda says:

    To me a professional review is only useful for fine dinning. And even then the restaurant usually goes completely out of their way to impress the reviewer and so you’re really not getting a true feel for what the restaurant is like on an average night. I take the normal, every day persons opinion a lot more seriously.

  2. Eric says:

    There is a place for both kinds of reviews — Ian Froeb, Joe Bonwich, Sauce, Feast, et al. do a fantastic job of letting us know in detail which sorts of new restaurants are buzz-worthy, but I practically don’t go out to eat at all anymore without consulting Yelp. A situation where there is only one reviewer in the whole city that everyone recognizes, and restaurants are always always kissing up to him for a good review and giving him a meal unlike what the average Joe can expect is the LAST thing that I want for St. Louis. (That said, that’s not a dig at Joe Pollock, I love his and Ann’s blog — it’s an unparalleled provider of photos of tasty local dishes.)

    My two cents.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>